Those of you who have already created Sankey diagrams might have come across the issue: As long as the flow data you are about to visualize is more or less in the same value range everything is fine, and there should be no problem in coming up with an nice Sankey diagram. However, sometimes we have very small flow quantities, while at the same time there are some large flows dominating the picture.

Sticking to the “golden rule” of Sankey diagrams (i.e. the width of the Sankey arrow corresponds to the flow quantity represented) and ensuring the proportionality of flows in relation to each other becomes very difficult. If you opt to show the larger flows at “normal” width, the smaller flows become difficult to perceive and are shown as hairlines (sometimes even invisible on a screen or in print). If, on the other hand, you decide to push up the scaling factor so that these smaller flow quantities can be seen in the diagram, then the large flows are really fat and spoil your diagram.

This seems to be an irresolvable issue… Nevertheless, there are some approaches to tackle this. Most of them resort to taking out the tiny flows or the very large flows of being to scale used in the Sankey diagram. You may opt to use a minimum width (e.g. 1 or 2 pixels) for arrows that carry only a small flow quantity, or you may decide to set an upper flow threshold, corresponding to a maximum width for the Sankey arrow, independent of the actual flow quantity (beyond the threshold value). In both cases I would strongly recommend to denote this decision in the diagram (e.g. in a footnote), since otherwise the person looking at the Sankey diagram will get a wrong idea of the quantities/proportions.

The Sankey diagram from the PROSUM report I recently featured in this post has another, quite unique solution. Here is a zoomed cropped section:

The metals in the end-of-life vehicle (ELV) stream of 8 million tons (in 2016) are mainly aluminium, copper and iron. This stream is on the same scale as the overall Sankey diagram (see full diagram here). However, the other metals in the stream (such as gold, silver or platinum) are contained in comparatively much smaller amounts. The authors of the Sankey diagram hence opted to emphasize them by switching to another scale (1:5.000). As a result the arrow representing the flow of approximately 660 tons of critical raw materials (CRMs) is almost a wide as the arrow that shows 6780 ktons!

The fact that the precious metal stream is highlighted and not to scale with the rest of the flows in the diagram is clearly signalled with a note, a dotted line that separates this diagram area, and even an exclamation mark symbol.

Since CRMs were the focus of the PROSUM study I think such a “trick” is justified. What are your experiences with flows on different scales? How would you handle this “dimension challenge” in a Sankey diagram? Let me know your ideas!

No Responses to “Handling Different Scales in one Diagram”

  1. vloansltd Says:

    alle sort l忙der nike free run vibram fivefingers speed bl氓 himmelbl氓 nike womens michael badgley limited whitepink jersey los angeles chargers nfl 4 rush fashion nike mike nugent mens orange elite jersey 2 nfl alternate cincinnati bengals mizuno wave creation 13 marinen air jordan 8 blu and arancia
    vloansltd [url=http://www.vloansltd.com/]vloansltd[/url]

  2. air jordan 5 quai 54 black radiant green Says:

    nike free 3.0 v5 distance blue bluejays femmes nike shox current rose blanc georgia boonie hat nike cortez new release blue jays blank blue new cool base stitched mlb jersey nike lance alworth navy blue backer los angeles chargers nfl 19 long sleeve t shirt
    air jordan 5 quai 54 black radiant green

  3. dam盲nner air jordan 9 minzgr眉n Says:

    dam盲nner nike zoom pegasus 31 gr眉n mujeres nike lunarglide 7 azul rojo nike air max thea olive gr酶n nike air max l忙r all svart mens asics gel hyper 33 yellow blue maschio asics asics gel kayano 17 blu verde
    dam盲nner air jordan 9 minzgr眉n

  4. Roselle Aceuedo Says:

    Your place is valueble for me. Thanks!…

  5. detroit pistons retro jersey Says:

    nike lebron lion scarpe oakley crosslink prescription sunglasses elite ryan succop jersey tennessee titans 8 alternate navy blue adidas eqt support trainers nike mercurial vapor 9 neptune blue nike air force 1 high sort brun
    detroit pistons retro jersey

  6. nike air force 1 low hvit grade school Says:

    kvinders asics gel kinsei 4 himmelbl氓 lilla maschio asics gel noosa tri 10 argento bianca kd 9 orange 2018 michael uptown astor shoulder bags large red nike air max tailwind 7 r酶d rosa nike zoom pegasus 34 femminile arancia rosa
    nike air force 1 low hvit grade school

  7. north face gore tex yellow jacket Says:

    chicago bears new era nfl fierce fill 39thirty cap air maxs femminile nike air max day 2018 rosa grigio nike free 5.0 schuhe schwarz air jordan retro 6 sort bl氓 gr氓 product image adidas mens pittsburgh penguins authentic pro player black performance pullover hoodie menn nike hyperrev 2015 pe paul george svart gr酶nn
    north face gore tex yellow jacket

  8. Laquanda Ondersma Says:

    There are some attention-grabbing time limits on this article but I don’t know if I see all of them middle to heart. There’s some validity however I will take maintain opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want extra! Added to FeedBurner as well

  9. nike air max 97 kvinners gul bl氓 Says:

    nike lebron 11 low turbo vert columbus blue jackets adidas nhl 100th celebration structured flex cap air jordan retro 10 rouge gamma bleu nike kobe 10 elite rosado amarillo air jordan 11 wolf grey nike air max schwarz wei脽 speckled
    nike air max 97 kvinners gul bl氓

  10. Toney Lindauer Says:

    There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made certain nice points in features also.

Leave a Reply