Another example of a national energy flow Sankey diagam, this time from Spain for 2009. To be found on page 40 of the recently published ‘La Energía en España 2009′ (large 10 MB PDF!) downloadable from the Ministry of Industry, Tourism and Commerce (MITYC) website. This is somewhat more advanced than the one from Spain I showed in this post.

Flows are in ‘ktep’ (ktoe, ‘kilo tonnes of oil equivalent, in Spanish), and percentages given are in relation to the total primary energy (130.508 ktep primary energy in 2009).

Nice and colorful, indeed. But again a good example of how to make mistakes (i.e. violate the basic rules) in drawing Sankey diagrams. So, here is the Sankey didactics part….

a) Arrows should be (no: must be!) to scale. Example: See blue arrow ‘USO FINAL’ with 16.1 % in comparison to blue arrow ‘consumo transformación’ with 19.1%
b) The same arrow should not change its width …
… while it runs in the same direction. Example: light green arrow ‘USO FINAL’ gets narrower as it runs vertically before branching to the sectors ‘Transporte’ and ‘Indústria’. Very weird!
… when it changes the direction. Example: pink arrow from the petroleum arrow going to the sector ‘Residencial’ is much wider on the vertical segment than on the horizontal segment.
c) An arrow should not maintain its magnitude …
… as it splits into two different flows. Example: green arrow ‘USO FINAL’ splits into two flows of the same width leading to the sectors ‘Residencial’ and ‘Industria’.
… as other flows branch off. Example: blue arrow ‘USO FINAL’ continues with the same magnitude to the sector ‘Residencial’, even though a considerable portion branches off to ‘Industria’.
d) It would be nice to have labels on all flows. Many negative examples, especially on the right hand side of the Sankey diagram.

Anyone care to do a better version?

5 Responses to “Energy Flows Spain 2009”

  1. Javier Alonso Says:

    You are puzzled by what look as errors, but we in Spain are used to displays that do not look right if you look closely to them. I recall reading a book titled “How to lie with statistics”…
    Well… kind of. I miss the times when Aznar was our president…

  2. phineas Says:

    @Javi: LOL! Los primeros ministros cambian pero la política sigue igual!

  3. Colm O'Gairbhith Says:

    Hi,

    First great website, I come back every so often hoping to find a web-based thing that does it all, but so far so bad.
    Two things :

    First, a sankey of World emissions in 2000, http://carbontracking.com/images/Sankey_2000_World_emissions.png
    The original is from pg 44. of http://www.unep.org/publications/ebooks/kick-the-habit/

    Second :

    There is a first attempt at using the raphaeljs graphics javascript library to create a sankey. Very alpha, but gives a starting point for someone who has the time to go for it. See http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4545254/sankey-diagram-in-javascript

    Anyway, keep it up, information must be free !

  4. Italy Energy Flows 2004 | Sankey Diagrams Says:

    [...] to the other national energy flow diagrams I have shown in previous posts here on the blog, such as this one for Spain, these two for the United Kingdom, or here for the United [...]

  5. Spain: Energy, CO2, Cost | Sankey Diagrams Says:

    [...] am aware that I was kind of ‘Sankey diagram bashing’ with my post on Spain energy flow diagram last December. Now here is another one from the Iberian penninsula that fully makes up for the first one. It is [...]